Science › Physics2 min read

Friction thickens the liquid layer on ice, making it slipperier: simulation and theory from Oslo and Jülich

A study in Physical Review Letters combines molecular simulations with friction theory. Frictional heat at contact points thickens the liquid film on ice and lowers friction.

Friction thickens the liquid layer on ice, making it slipperier: simulation and theory from Oslo and Jülich
Photo: NASA Goddard Space Flight Center from Greenbelt, MD, USA, Wikimedia Commons, Public domain · License: Public domain

Physicists from the University of Oslo and Forschungszentrum Jülich have published a study in Physical Review Letters that links two long-debated explanations for why ice is slippery. According to spektrum.de, the work combines molecular-scale simulations with results from real experiments into a single picture spektrum.despektrum.despektrum.deOpen source ↗. The research group in Oslo is led by Sigbjørn Løland Bore, who works with Henrik Andersen Sveinsson and Bo Persson of the Institute of Solid State Research at Jülich.

Two known causes, neither sufficient alone

One explanation is premelting: even below freezing, a thin liquid layer permanently covers ice, at least at the interface with air. It remains an open question how pronounced this effect is, because experiments do not show how stable the layer is on contact with other surfaces. The layer also becomes thinner and more viscous at very low temperatures.

The second explanation is frictional heating, which warms the ice surface and produces a thin lubricating film. By itself this does not suffice either, since a person slips on ice before any frictional heat can arise.

To examine the interplay, Bore modelled the contact between numerous water and silicon dioxide molecules, representing a stone sliding on ice. The calculations covered different temperatures and speeds and gave the thickness and viscosity of the premelting layer and the friction forces. At minus 89 degrees Celsius the ice surface still remained covered by a thin liquid layer, and motion across it increased the layer further through friction spektrum.despektrum.despektrum.deOpen source ↗.

Bridging the molecular and macroscopic scales

The nanoscale simulations did not match reality on their own. The calculated friction was much larger than measured and rose with speed, whereas in experiments friction falls as an object moves faster.

The authors therefore turned to Persson, an expert in friction who had developed formulas for sliding on ice in 2015. On the macroscale, true contact occurs only at small asperities, and frictional heat concentrates there. This local heating makes the lubricating film much thicker. Persson's mathematics allowed the authors to move between scales without contradiction.

In the resulting picture, a lubricating premelting layer is already present at rest. The largest contribution comes from friction, which heats countless contact points to near the melting point. The liquid layer then becomes markedly thicker and considerably less viscous, and friction decreases spektrum.despektrum.despektrum.deOpen source ↗.

Sources · 1

Found a mistake?
  1. ↩

Read also

Up next

The next story opens automatically

More
Follow us

Type at least two letters — results appear instantly

↑↓to choose↵to openescto close