Cornell team finds a phase boundary in UTe2 where superconductivity is partly lost on cooling
Ultrasound measurements of uranium ditelluride under pressure reveal a tetracritical point, resolving a thermodynamically forbidden triple point in its phase diagram.

A research team from Cornell University and colleagues studied uranium ditelluride (UTe2) under pressure with ultrasound and found a new phase boundary where part of the superconducting order disappears on cooling. The work, by Sahas Kamat and co-authors, was published in Nature Physics and is available on nature.com nature.com
nature.comnature.comOpen source ↗. UTe2 is a candidate topological superconductor with several superconducting states. The authors report that the new boundary is marked by an upward jump in sound velocity, which they treat as direct thermodynamic evidence of a transition in which superconducting order is lost on cooling.
A tetracritical point instead of a triple point
The pressure–temperature phase diagram of UTe2 had appeared to show two intersecting second-order phase boundaries at a triple point. Thermodynamics forbids such a configuration, which pointed either to a hidden transition or to a misunderstanding of superconductivity in this material. The new boundary resolves the contradiction. The authors establish a tetracritical point at about 0.20 GPa and 1.6 K, where four phases meet: the normal state, SC1, SC2 and the mixed SC1+SC2 state. Beyond this point the ambient-pressure and pressure-induced order parameters form a multicomponent state.
Ultrasound measurements and the model
The team used pulse-echo ultrasound and tracked the elastic moduli c11, c33 and c55 at fixed pressures from 0 to 1 GPa, with close attention to the region near 0.20 GPa. At 0.213 GPa and zero magnetic field, c11 showed three discontinuities on cooling: the first two downward, the last upward. The authors interpret the last one, near 1.0 K, as the loss of the SC2 component while SC1 superconductivity persists. Cooling and warming runs showed no hysteresis, consistent with a second-order transition. The phase assignment rests on thermodynamic relations between elastic moduli and heat capacity rather than on a direct heat capacity measurement.
The boundary is narrow: about 0.01 GPa wide, against an absolute pressure accuracy of 0.05 GPa. The pressure variation within the sample therefore had to be kept below 0.01 GPa. The ultrasonic transducer was about 100 micrometres across and the sample about 300 micrometres thick.
Using the measured phase diagram, the authors built a phenomenological Ginzburg–Landau model. They report that strong competition between the two superconducting order parameters drives the loss of order on cooling and leads to phase locking that suppresses superconducting fluctuations nature.com
nature.comnature.comOpen source ↗. The order parameter amplitudes in the model are calculated, not measured directly. The study does not demonstrate the topological nature of the state. The authors present the result as the definitive magnetic field–pressure–temperature phase diagram of UTe2 and as a thermodynamic foundation for multicomponent superconductivity. The measured data are openly available on GitHub.
Sources · 2
Found a mistake?Read also



