Life › Agritech2 min read

Meta-analysis of 26 articles: edible coatings preserve walnut kernel antioxidants better than packaging

A meta-analysis of postharvest studies found that coating kept more total phenols and antioxidant activity in walnut kernels, while packaging showed no significant effect on them.

Meta-analysis of 26 articles: edible coatings preserve walnut kernel antioxidants better than packaging
Photo: Potkettle, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0 · License: CC BY 3.0

A meta-analysis published in the Journal of Agriculture and Food Research compared how coating and packaging preserve the chemical quality of walnut kernels after harvest. The work covered 26 articles with 62 individual studies and evaluated 9 chemical parameters of fresh and dried kernels sciencedirect.comJournal of Agriculture and Food Researchsciencedirect.comOpen source ↗.

Data and method

Coating and packaging are widely used to maintain kernel quality after harvest. Individual trials, however, reported conflicting conclusions about which approach gives better chemical protection. The authors pooled the published results with a random-effects model, comparing treated kernels with untreated controls.

The bias assessment used two methods. After it, 8 parameters were free of bias, and the conclusions below rest on them. According to the publication's summary, kernels of Persian walnut (Juglans regia) are rich in polyunsaturated fatty acids, which makes them vulnerable to rancidity, browning and chemical breakdown during distribution. The coatings in the reviewed studies were polysaccharide- or protein-based, for example carboxymethyl cellulose, chitosan or zein. The packaging methods included modified atmosphere and vacuum sealing.

Coating against packaging

Coating significantly reduced moisture loss and better preserved total phenol content and antioxidant activity. Packaging did not significantly affect these parameters sciencedirect.comJournal of Agriculture and Food Researchsciencedirect.comOpen source ↗. Both approaches significantly decreased peroxide value, an early marker of lipid oxidation, and neither changed color chromaticity.

Overall, coating treatments showed better and more consistent effects than packaging. Per the secondary summary, neither approach significantly changed acid value. Adding antioxidants to the coating gave no significant additional reduction in peroxide value compared with a coating without them.

The authors state that the results can serve as guidance for maintaining the quality of fresh and dried kernels. This is a statistical synthesis of earlier experiments, not a new storage trial, so its conclusions are limited to the parameters and treatments covered by the pooled studies.

Sources · 2

Found a mistake?
  1. ↩

Read also

Up next

The next story opens automatically

More
Follow us

Type at least two letters — results appear instantly

↑↓to choose↵to openescto close