Life › Agritech2 min read

Norway farm model: national manure trade could cut mineral phosphorus imports by 78%

A model of about 40,000 Norwegian farms shows manure trade could cut mineral phosphorus imports by 78% and soil accumulation by 80%, easing western surpluses.

Norway farm model: national manure trade could cut mineral phosphorus imports by 78%
Photo: GoldenArtists, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0 · License: CC BY 4.0

Researchers quantified phosphorus (P) cycles on about 40,000 Norwegian farms for 2019–2023 and tested four manure redistribution strategies. The results were published in the Journal of Industrial Ecology. In the simulation, manure trade at the national level lowers mineral P imports by 78% and soil accumulation by 80% springer.comJournal of Industrial Ecologyspringer.comOpen source ↗. The analysis combines substance flow analysis with farm subsidy statistics and aggregates farm results to municipal, county and national levels.

Phosphorus flows in Norwegian agriculture

Norwegian agriculture applies 22.1 kt P per year to cropland. Of this, 4% is lost to runoff and 41% accumulates in soils, particularly in the livestock-dense western regions. The inputs are 8.5 kt from imported mineral fertilizers, 3.4 kt from sewage sludge and composted biowaste, and 10.2 kt from collected manure. Crops take up 11.6 kt, runoff removes 1.1 kt, and 9.0 kt stays in the soil.

Only 9% of harvested crop P goes to direct human consumption, while 91% goes to animal feed. Livestock take in 18.7 kt P per year, and 6.4 kt of it is imported as concentrate feed ingredients. Also, 28.5% of farms keep no livestock, and about 44% of livestock farms produce enough manure P for their own crops yet still apply mineral fertilizer.

The regional imbalance is large. In Western Norway, Hå produces 344 t of manure P with a surplus of 206 t, Klepp 248 t with a surplus of 149 t, and Time 222 t with a surplus of 156 t. In Eastern Norway, grain and vegetable production creates deficits: Nes −162 t, Indre Østfold −147 t, Lillestrøm −111 t.

Four redistribution scenarios

The model kept livestock densities and crop patterns unchanged. On-farm optimization, which assumes perfect information and no technical constraints within a holding, reduces mineral P use by 38% and soil accumulation by 36%, to 5.8 kt per year springer.comJournal of Industrial Ecologyspringer.comOpen source ↗. Trade within municipalities lowers P imports by 61%, about 5.5 kt per year, and soil accumulation by 65%, to 3.2 kt per year.

Extending trade to the county level adds only a further 4% reduction in imports and 2% in soil accumulation. National trade gives the largest effect: 78% less imported P and 80% less soil accumulation.

The authors provide a reproducible method for building national multi-scale P analyses. They report that the results show where local management is sufficient and where further processing and trade are required.

Sources · 2

Found a mistake?
  1. ↩

Read also

Up next

The next story opens automatically

More
Follow us

Type at least two letters — results appear instantly

↑↓to choose↵to openescto close