# University of Girona study: over 50% of analysed websites track users despite their banner choices

- Published: 2026-11-22 08:04 UTC
- Section: Digital & Computing › Data security
- Tags: website tracking without consent, University of Girona study, consent banner, data protection, David Martínez, web privacy audit, Spanish Data Protection Agency, browser tracking
- URL: https://realtech.media/news/rt-9b5a01312387d493490f94ef_university_of_girona/

**Researchers at the University of Girona found that over half of analysed sites track users regardless of their consent banner choice. A tool for auditing sites is now in development.**

![University of Girona study: over 50% of analysed websites track users despite their banner choices](https://realtech.media/media/2026/11/b030e4c191904f72.webp)
*cope.es*

Researchers at the University of Girona (UdG) report that more than half of the websites they analysed track users without real consent and ignore the choices made in consent banners, cope.es reported on 22 November 2026 [1]. The study was led by David Martínez of the Communications and Distributed Systems Group at UdG [1]. It grew out of curiosity about what actually happens "under the hood" of browsers.

## How the discrepancy was found

Martínez and his team noticed irregularities: the data obtained from tracking on websites did not match what the user had selected in the banner beforehand [1]. They then developed algorithms and models to analyse the phenomenon at scale, which showed that these were not isolated cases. The main result is that more than 50% of the websites examined engage in these practices [1].

According to Martínez, the situation verges on illegality, since it conflicts with current data protection rules. He adds that for an ordinary user it is impossible to know what goes on inside the browser.

Responsibility depends on the type of site. Large corporations manage millions of users, and their business model rests on mass data collection. Small businesses and individuals may be unaware of it: if an owner embeds a link to a YouTube video, Google places trackers there, and the owner may not realise it, Martínez explains.

## Oversight and the next step

The collected data on browsing habits, searches and interests is used to build detailed profiles for personalised advertising, according to the researcher. He rejects the idea that phones listen to users, citing technical complexity and the high battery consumption it would require. In his view, the impression comes from how effective current tracking systems are.

Oversight belongs to data protection authorities such as the Spanish Data Protection Agency or its Catalan counterpart. If they receive information about irregularities, they can start an audit that ends in fines and legal proceedings [1]. Martínez admits that the volume of work involved in supervising the whole Internet means the institutions cannot cover everything.

The UdG team is in contact with Spanish and European authorities to pass on its findings. With ministry funding, it has started a new research project to develop a tool that would let both users and authorities audit websites in a simple way [1].

## Sources

1. [cope.es](https://www.cope.es/emisoras/catalunya/girona-provincia/girona/noticias/estudio-destapa-gran-mentira-cookies-50-webs-te-espian-permiso-20261122_3478191.html)

---

Source: RealTech, realtech.media — https://realtech.media/news/rt-9b5a01312387d493490f94ef_university_of_girona/
